# Clan performance traffic light in Clash of Clans: who isn't contributing and why

> Rank the 50 members of your clan into Pillars, On Watch, and Candidates for Rotation with three objective criteria —war attacks, donation ratio, and Capital— along with the written reason for each. No registration required.

- **Source (source):** https://aitoolsforapps.com/clash-of-clans-bases-upgrades-ore-armies-227/f/member-performance-traffic-light
- **Platform (platform):** AiToolsForApps
- **Language (language):** en

## In summary

- Performance Traffic Light: who supports the clan and who holds it back, with the written reason
- The 50 members divided into Pillars, On Watch, and Candidates for Rotation with three objective criteria, and beneath each name the exact phrase that placed them there.
- The literal reason, not a number
- Three criteria and all three are verifiable
- Prudence by design

## Performance Traffic Light: who supports the clan and who holds it back, with the written reason

Paste your clan's public tag in the Clan tab and switch from List to Traffic Light. The same roster of up to 50 members is regrouped into three blocks —Candidates for Rotation in red, On Watch in amber, and Pillars in green, plus a fourth block for New members, with no data— and each row carries its literal reason written below the name, not an opaque score from 1 to 100.

The reasons are phrases like '1 out of 2 attacks in the ongoing war', 'failed attacks in 3 of the last 5 recorded wars', 'donation ratio 0.18: 740 received, 133 donated' or 'zero attacks in the last weekend of capital'. If a member accumulates several, the first one appears in the row and the rest expand when clicked. Those with no incidents state it just as clearly: 'attacks, donates, and participates: no incidents'.

There are three criteria and nothing more: attacks from the ongoing war and from your historical wars, the donation ratio based on a minimum of received troops, and participation in Clan Capital raids. Clan Games are not evaluated because the official Supercell API does not expose them, and we prefer to say it upfront rather than filling the gap with an estimate. The thresholds are set in the service configuration and are written in the 'How is this calculated?' sheet, which opens from the traffic light itself.

And a caution that is the reason for the tool's existence: no one enters red without sufficient basis. A member with no recorded wars, no weekend of capital, and no history remains in 'New, no data' and is not classified. A bad donation ratio, by itself, reaches at most amber: to turn red, war attacks without spending are needed. If a piece is missing —no active war, no recorded capital, or you don't have history yet— the traffic light warns you at the top instead of hiding that it judges with everything.

## What's included

- **The literal reason, not a number** — each member has the phrase that classifies them written out, with their figures included. It's what you can read to the affected person when they ask why.
- **Three criteria and all three are verifiable** — attacks from the ongoing war, failed wars in your history, and donation ratio above a minimum of received, plus participation in Clan Capital raids.
- **Prudence by design** — no one is marked red without a base. Newcomers go to a separate block of 'New, no data' and the donation ratio, by itself, never goes red.
- **Thresholds in sight** — the sheet 'How is this calculated?' shows the minimum troops received, the ratio cuts, and how many failed wars turn amber or red. No black box.
- **Says what it doesn't know** — if there is no active war, no registered capital weekends, and no history yet, the traffic light warns on screen and limits the ranking to the data it does have.
- **It's the same list, not another screen** — a switch toggles from the sortable roster to the traffic light and back, and from any row you enter the member's profile.
- **No registration and no credentials** — works as a guest with the clan's public tag. The app does not access your Clash of Clans account, does not modify it, and does not generate gems or resources.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### How do I know who is not contributing in my Clash of Clans clan?

Paste the clan's public tag in the Clan tab of the Clash of Clans app on AiToolsForApps (aitoolsforapps.com) and switch the toggle from List to Traffic Light. Up to 50 members are categorized into Candidates for Rotation, On Watch, and Pillars, plus a block for New members without data, and each row has the exact reason written below: the attacks they are missing in the ongoing war, failed wars in your history, their donation ratio with the numbers of donations given and received, or their attacks from the last weekend of Capital. No registration or game credentials are required.

### What criteria does it use to classify members? Is it an AI score?

There is no AI or opaque scoring in this classification: it uses three deterministic criteria calculated from public data. One, the attacks from the ongoing war and those from wars recorded in your history (failing several of the last ones turns red, failing one turns amber). Two, the donation ratio, which is only evaluated based on a minimum of troops received in the cycle to avoid penalizing those who rarely ask. Three, participation in Clan Capital raids: zero attacks in the last weekend are marked. Clan Games are not evaluated because Supercell's official API does not publish that data. The specific thresholds are detailed in the sheet 'How is this calculated?' that opens from the traffic light itself.

### Can it mark someone red who just joined the clan?

No, and it's intentional. A member with no wars, no Capital weekends, and no recorded history stays in the 'New, no data' block and is not classified. Additionally, red requires war attacks without spending: a bad donation ratio, by itself, can only reach amber at most. And if a source is missing—no active war, no Capital seasons, or you don't have a history yet—the traffic light warns you above and limits the classification to what can be verified, instead of assuming an incomplete picture is valid.

### Is the data live? What happens if there is no reading from the official API?

The traffic light is calculated based on what the official Supercell API returns at the time of the query, plus the historical wars you have been capturing. To put it bluntly: the live reading of that API is not yet activated on this server, so today the clan tab shows that notice on screen instead of inventing a roster. As soon as access is active, the traffic light loads with the same tag. In the meantime, the rest of the app—base catalog, upgrade planner, ores calculator, and army catalog—works fully and without registration.

### Can I change the thresholds or save the history of failed wars?

The thresholds (minimum received troops, ratio cuts, and how many failed wars move to amber or red) reside in the service configuration, not in a user panel: they are the same for everyone and are published in the traffic light spreadsheet, so the classification is auditable. The history is yours: with a free account, you can track the clan and take snapshots, which gives rise to the criteria for failed wars; CSV export, favorite clans, and alerts for recurring members with their evidence are also added. Checking the traffic light does not require an account.

- [Clash of Clans — Bases, Upgrade Calculator and Armies by Town Hall Level](https://aitoolsforapps.com/clash-of-clans-bases-upgrades-ore-armies-227)

## About the platform

**Clash of Clans — Bases, Upgrade Calculator and Armies by Town Hall Level** — an app by AiToolsForApps. Available at: https://aitoolsforapps.com/clash-of-clans-bases-upgrades-ore-armies-227/f/member-performance-traffic-light

### Other languages

- `es`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/es/clash-of-clans-bases-mejoras-ores-ejercitos-227/f/semaforo-de-rendimiento-de-miembros
- `fr`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/fr/clash-of-clans-bases-ameliorations-minerais-armees-227/f/feu-tricolore-de-performance-des-membres
- `it`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/it/clash-of-clans-basi-potenziamenti-minerali-eserciti-227/f/semaforo-di-performance-dei-membri
- `pt`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/pt/clash-of-clans-bases-melhorias-minerios-exercitos-227/f/semaforo-de-rendimento-de-membros
- `de`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/de/clash-of-clans-basen-upgrades-erz-armeen-227/f/leistungsampel-der-mitglieder
- `bg`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/bg/clash-of-clans-bazi-po-th-kalkulator-na-podobreniya-i-na-ores-i-armii-na-meta-227/f/svetofar-na-predstavyaneto-na-chlenovete
- `ja`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/ja/clash-of-clans-base-upgrade-calculator-army-227/f/member-performance-shingo
- `nl`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/nl/clash-of-clans-bases-per-th-upgrade-en-ore-calculator-en-meta-legers-227/f/prestatiestoplicht-voor-leden
- `da`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/da/clash-of-clans-baser-pr-th-opgraderings-og-ore-beregner-og-meta-haere-227/f/traflylys-for-medlemmers-praestation
- `ko`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/ko/clash-of-clans-base-upgrade-calculator-227/f/clan-member-performance-traffic-light
- `sv`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/sv/clash-of-clans-baser-per-th-uppgraderings-och-ore-kalkylator-samt-meta-armeer-227/f/prestandatrafikljus-for-klanmedlemmar
- `fi`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/fi/clash-of-clans-tukikohdat-th-n-mukaan-paivitys-ja-ores-laskurit-seka-metan-armeijat-227/f/jasenten-suorituskykyliikennevalo
- `no`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/no/clash-of-clans-baser-per-th-oppgraderings-og-ore-kalkulator-og-meta-haerer-227/f/ytelsestrafikklys-for-medlemmer
- `id`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/id/clash-of-clans-base-per-th-kalkulator-peningkatan-dan-ore-serta-pasukan-meta-227/f/lampu-lalu-lintas-performa-anggota
- `cs`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/cs/clash-of-clans-zakladny-podle-th-kalkulacka-vylepseni-a-oru-a-armady-mety-227/f/semafor-vykonu-clenu
- `he`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/he/clash-of-clans-bsisim-lpi-th-mchshbon-shdrogim-v-ores-vtsbaot-hmta-227/f/ramzor-bitzuim-shel-chaverim
- `ar`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/ar/clash-of-clans-quaad-bhsb-th-whasba-ttuirat-waurz-wjiush-almita-227/f/ishart-murur-adaa-alaadaa
- `pl`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/pl/clash-of-clans-bazy-wedlug-th-kalkulator-ulepszen-i-orow-oraz-armie-mety-227/f/sygnalizator-wynikow-czlonkow
- `zh`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/zh/clash-of-clans-bases-upgrade-calculator-armies-227/f/clash-of-clans-member-performance-traffic-light
