# Genshin Impact Weapon Comparator | 5★ from the banner or R5?

> Compare weapons and refinements R1-R5 with your Genshin Impact build: ordered rotation damage and a warning if you run out of Energy Recharge. Free, no registration or UID required.

- **Source (source):** https://aitoolsforapps.com/genshin-impact-damage-artifact-wish-calculator-237/f/weapon-comparator-and-refinements
- **Platform (platform):** AiToolsForApps
- **Language (language):** en

## In summary

- Weapon and Refinement Comparator for Genshin Impact
- Should I pull for the 5★ weapon from the banner or stick with my 4★ at R5? Set your fixed build, change only the weapon, and see the rotation damage of each candidate, sorted from highest to lowest.
- One single variable
- Ranked by rotation damage
- Refinements from R1 to R5 at a glance

## Weapon and Refinement Comparator for Genshin Impact

The comparator starts from the build you already have set up: your character, your five artifacts, your buffs, and the same enemy. The only thing that changes is the weapon. This makes the comparison clean: the difference you see on screen is solely due to the weapon and nothing else.

You can add any weapons you want from the catalog — it only offers those of the type your character uses, so there’s no way to mistakenly compare a sword with a claymore — and choose their refinement from R1 to R5 with a tap. For each candidate, your final stats and complete rotation damage are recalculated, and the list is sorted by damage: the one that hits hardest is at the top, crowned, and below each one with the exact percentage it loses compared to it.

And importantly: it tells you WHAT YOU LOSE. Each row shows the change stat by stat compared to the weapon you’re using — HP, ATK, CRIT Rate, CRIT DMG, Elemental Mastery, and Energy Recharge, in green what goes up and in red what goes down — and if a candidate leaves you below your character's Energy Recharge requirement, it states it clearly: gains in damage, but you’re left without Elemental Burst in each rotation. Once you’ve decided, the button "Equip this" adds it to your build with its refinement, and the rest of the calculators continue from there.

Everything is calculated on your own mobile with the game's formulas: it's instant, free, and does not ask for your UID or access your account. It is an independent tool from AiToolsForApps, not affiliated with HoYoverse or COGNOSPHERE, and does not modify the game.

## What's included

- **One single variable** — keep your character, your five artifacts, your buffs, and the same enemy intact and change only the weapon. The difference you see is from the weapon, not the noise of two different builds.
- **Ranked by rotation damage** — the winner on top with a crown and each of the others with the exact percentage they lose against her. No interpretation needed.
- **Refinements from R1 to R5 at a glance** — answers the real question of the banner —5★ weapon at R1 vs your 4★ at R5— without having to redo the build or open a spreadsheet.
- **It tells you what you lose** — if a candidate leaves you below your character's Energy Recharge requirement, the warning appears in her own row. Gain in damage but lose your Elemental Burst: that's not an upgrade.
- **Stat differences one by one** — HP, ATK, CRIT Rate, CRIT DMG, Elemental Mastery, and Energy Recharge compared to the weapon you have, in green what increases and in red what decreases.
- **Only your character's weapons** — filter the catalog by weapon type, so a Hu Tao only compares polearms. And if your weapon isn't in the catalog, Manual Mode lets you input its base ATK and sub-stat manually.
- **Conservative comparison** — only counts what the weapon always provides. Passives that require a condition —"against enemies affected by Hydro", "at 7 stacks"— are shown on the build screen and you activate them, so no candidate wins with a scenario that isn't met.
- **Decide and continue** — "Equip this" places the selected weapon with its refinement in your build, and the damage calculator and artifact optimizer continue from there. Free, no registration, and no UID required.

## Frequently Asked Questions

### Is the 5★ weapon from the banner worth it or should I stick with my 4★ at R5?

It depends on your build, and that's exactly what the comparator calculates. Set up your character with its five artifacts, add both weapons to the list, set the 5★ to R1 and the 4★ to R5, and compare the damage of your full rotation against the same enemy with the same buffs. Often, the refined 4★ is just a few percentage points shy of the 5★ at R1; other times the difference is significant. The comparator gives you the numbers with your artifacts, not those from a video.

### How much damage do I gain by refining a weapon from R1 to R5 in Genshin Impact?

Add the weapon to the list and click R1, R2, R3, R4, and R5: at each step, your final stats and rotation damage are recalculated, so you see the actual gain in your build. Keep one thing in mind: passives that require a condition to activate (for example, "against enemies affected by Hydro or Pyro") only count if you mark that condition on the build screen; otherwise, refinement only adjusts what the weapon provides permanently. It's intentional: we prefer to underpromise than to guarantee damage that depends on the scenario being fulfilled.

### How do I know if switching weapons will leave me without Energy Recharge?

The comparator monitors it for you. Each candidate shows its difference in Recharge compared to the weapon you're using, and if it leaves you below your character's requirement, a warning appears in its row telling you what percentage of Recharge you have and what you need. It's the classic trap of switching from a weapon with Recharge sub-stat to one with CRIT DMG: the damage per hit increases, but the rotation breaks because the Elemental Burst no longer occurs in every cycle.

### Do I need an account, UID, or inventory scanner to compare weapons?

No. The comparator works fully without registration: no UID is requested, your Genshin account is not read, no scripts or proxies are needed, and the game is not modified. You manually enter your build, and the calculation runs in your own browser, so it's instantaneous and nothing leaves your game. The free AiToolsForApps account is only for saving builds and generating the team rotation guide with AI.

### Where do the base ATK, substats, and weapon passives come from?

From a curated catalog within the tool itself, featuring 57 weapons of the five types and their values at level 90. We state on-screen: each data block carries the version of the game it was calibrated against and the label 'unverified' until it has been cross-checked piece by piece, and the passives that the calculator cannot translate into a number (energy particles, extra ATK based on another stat) are noted as 'not applied to calculation' instead of fabricating a value. We prefer to tell you where each number comes from rather than pretend an accuracy we cannot prove.

- [Genshin Impact — Damage, Artifact & Wish Calculator with AI](https://aitoolsforapps.com/genshin-impact-damage-artifact-wish-calculator-237)

## About the platform

**Genshin Impact — Damage, Artifact & Wish Calculator with AI** — an app by AiToolsForApps. Available at: https://aitoolsforapps.com/genshin-impact-damage-artifact-wish-calculator-237/f/weapon-comparator-and-refinements

### Other languages

- `es`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/es/genshin-impact-calculadora-dano-artefactos-tiradas-237/f/comparador-de-armas-y-refinamientos
- `fr`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/fr/genshin-impact-calculateur-degats-artefacts-voeux-237/f/comparateur-d-armes-et-raffinements
- `it`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/it/genshin-impact-calcolatore-danni-artefatti-wish-237/f/comparatore-di-armi-e-raffinamenti
- `pt`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/pt/genshin-impact-calculadora-dano-artefatos-desejos-237/f/comparador-de-armas-e-refinamentos
- `de`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/de/genshin-impact-schaden-artefakt-wunsch-rechner-237/f/waffenvergleich-und-raffinierungen
- `bg`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/bg/kalkulator-na-shteti-i-artefakti-za-genshin-impact-pity-i-bild-237/f/sravnitel-na-oruzhia-i-rafinirania-genshin
- `nl`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/nl/schade-en-artefactcalculator-genshin-impact-pity-en-build-237/f/wapenvergelijker-en-refinements
- `ja`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/ja/genshin-impact-damage-artifact-calculator-237/f/genshin-buki-hikaku-seiren
- `ko`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/ko/genshin-impact-damage-artifact-calculator-237/f/genshin-mugi-bigyo-jeongryeon
- `sv`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/sv/skade-och-artefaktkalkylator-for-genshin-impact-pity-237/f/vapenjamforare-och-refinements
- `da`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/da/skades-og-artefaktberegner-til-genshin-impact-pity-og-build-237/f/vaabensammenligner-og-refinements
- `zh`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/zh/genshin-impact-damage-calculator-237/f/weapon-and-refinement-comparator
- `pl`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/pl/kalkulator-obrazen-i-artefaktow-genshin-impact-pity-i-build-237/f/porownywarka-broni-i-ulepszen
- `no`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/no/skade-og-artefaktkalkulator-for-genshin-impact-pity-og-build-237/f/vapensammenligner-og-forbedringer
- `fi`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/fi/genshin-impactin-vahinko-ja-artefaktilaskuri-pity-ja-build-237/f/asevertailija-ja-jalostukset
- `ar`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/ar/hasba-drr-wqta-genshin-impact-alathria-pity-walbna-237/f/muqarin-alasliha-wa-altahsinat
- `id`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/id/kalkulator-damage-dan-artifact-genshin-impact-pity-dan-build-237/f/pembanding-senjata-dan-refinement
- `he`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/he/mchshbon-nzk-vartipktim-l-genshin-impact-pity-vbild-237/f/weapon-and-refinement-comparator
- `cs`: https://aitoolsforapps.com/cs/kalkulacka-poskozeni-a-artefaktu-genshin-impact-pity-a-build-237/f/porovnavac-zbrani-a-refinementu
