Upgrade or discard?

Genshin Impact Artifact Evaluator: Upgrade to +20 or Discard?

You input the piece as you see it —slot, level, main stat, and substats— and it returns the remaining rolls, the expected Crit Value at the end, the P10/P50/P90 percentiles, and a verdict at three levels. All without spending Mora to find out.

Upgrading a 5★ artifact to +20 costs a mountain of Mora and fodder, and often ends up in the discard pile. That decision is made earlier, with numbers, not later with regret.

The evaluator works piece by piece. You choose the slot (flower, plume, sands of eon, goblet, or circlet), the rarity (5★ or 4★), and the level you currently have: +0, +4, +8, +12, or +16. Then the main stat and the substats you can see: you tap the substat and then one of its four possible roll values, and each tap adds one more roll. If you go over, ‘Remove one’ corrects it without deleting the rest. It’s designed to avoid touching the keyboard if you don’t want to.

With that, it calculates how many rolls are left until its maximum level and distributes those rolls among its substats in 3,000 different scenarios. It returns the current Crit Value, the expected one at +20, and the P10, P50, and P90 percentiles displayed on a bar: the bad case, the normal case, and the good case. The sampling is deterministic, so the same piece always gives the same number, and you can come back tomorrow and compare.

If the piece still has a free slot, it also tells you the probability that the fourth unlocked substat will be useful, with a breakdown of each candidate and their appearance percentage. That part is weighted with the character's weights you have chosen in the Build tab: what is useful for a reaction bearer is not useful for a double crit DPS. If no character is selected, the verdict itself warns you that it is measuring pure double crit.

The result is summarized in three levels, with the explanatory phrase alongside: upgrade to +20, upgrade to +8 and reevaluate, or discard it as fodder. And it’s designed for quick bursts: the ‘Evaluate another piece’ button clears the substats and level but keeps the slot and rarity, allowing you to process ten pieces in a row after a farming session.

No sign-up

Try Upgrade or discard? right here

Loading the tool…

Use it free without an account. If you want to save your result, you can sign up afterwards.

Save / Sign up

Benefits of Upgrade or discard?

Verdict in three levels, not just a number to interpret

upgrade to +20, upgrade to +8 and reevaluate, or discard as fodder — with the reason written below, including your own percentiles within the phrase.

Percentiles, not just the average

P10, P50, and P90 of the final Crit Value on a bar. The average hides exactly what matters to you, which is how much can go wrong with the distribution of the remaining rolls.

3,000 scenarios and always the same result

the sampling distributes the remaining rolls among the substats and their four possible values, but it is deterministic. The same piece gives the same number today and tomorrow: it’s not a roulette.

The fourth substat, with its actual probability

if there is a free slot, we tell you the likelihood that what comes out will be useful, with the appearance percentage of each candidate weighted for your character.

Remaining rolls in sight

a piece gains one roll every four levels, so at +0 it has five left and at +16 only one. That number decides if the piece still has potential or if it's already set.

Threshold taken from the catalog, not invented

your percentiles are compared with the proportional contribution of a balanced piece to the Crit Value ranges of an entire build. And when the character is missing, the verdict speaks loudly.

Tap input for burst mode

slot and rarity stay fixed, 'Evaluate another piece' clears the rest, and in ten seconds you have the next one evaluated. Ten pieces in a row after farming, frictionless.

Free, no registration, and no UID required

the entire calculation runs in your own browser. Your account is not read, UID is not requested, nothing needs to be installed, and the game is not touched.

Before the next +20, run it through here

No registration, no UID, and no installation needed. Create a free account only if you want to save your named builds.

In the features that use AI, responses are generated by artificial intelligence and are not a substitute for professional advice.

Upgrade or discard? Genshin Impact artifact evaluator